Once upon a time, people dressed sharply, minded their manners, and worried about how their behavior reflected on their families and communities. Sure, this was partly driven by vanity, but it was also useful. Such prosocial vanity is maligned by modern standards as shallow, but it was not shallow; it served a purpose: it kept people accountable to others and reinforced the discipline of meeting shared standards.
Over the last century, the focus has shifted from fitting into a group to obsessing over oneself. Psychology—especially clinical practice—and its infiltration into popular and organizational culture played a major role in this shift, and not for the better. A culture that relentlessly promotes positive self-esteem has left individuals fragile, schools dysfunctional, and society weaker.
The rise of psychology as a profession created a problem: there were more trained “helpers” than people in need of clinical care. The solution was to expand psychology into schools, workplaces, and everyday life, promoting self-esteem as a cure-all. Children were told they couldn’t learn unless they felt good about themselves; workers were told they couldn’t succeed without positive self-image and belonging. Entire generations were trained to see self-acceptance, not excellence, as the highest goal.
[RELATED: Helicopter Parenting Won’t Get Your Child into Harvard]
It was a convenient solution. The new gospel of self-esteem guaranteed an endless demand for workshops, consultants, counselors, and specialists. But it also guaranteed a cultural pivot: away from the rigors of improvement and toward the fragility of ego maintenance.
The cost of selfish vanity shows up everywhere. Individuals now crumble at criticism, not because critique is cruel, but because they’ve been trained to equate feedback with threat. Confidence is defended, not earned. “Lived experience” is truth. And growth is optional, as long as one feels validated. Yet, despite this shifting focus, depression, anxiety, and other psychological problems are ever-rising.
Education has taken the hardest hit. Feedback, once the engine of progress, is now treated like an attack. Students resist correction, fearing it may puncture their inflated self-esteem, while teachers—steeped in psychological rhetoric—soften or avoid honest appraisals to protect students or themselves. The result: rigor disappears, weaknesses harden, and strengths never fully develop. Classrooms shift from places of mastery to sanctuaries of fragile egos, and talent drowns in a sea of mediocrity.
On an individual level, this is damaging, but society also pays a heavy price.
When everyone is focused inward, jealously guarding their self-esteem, collective progress slows. Innovation requires failure, and cooperation requires accountability and engagement. Neither of these is possible in a culture obsessed with protecting feelings over producing results. Our social fabric, once strengthened by prosocial vanity’s demand to “show up” for the group, now frays under the pull of self-preoccupation.
This shift has also eroded our fundamental social drives: building relationships and raising children. Prosocial vanity anchors people to family and community, but selfish vanity elevates self-development as the ultimate goal. When self-esteem and self-validation are prized above all else, commitment to partners, children, or anything beyond oneself feels like a threat. Relationships demand sacrifice, and parenting requires attention, energy, and resources for others. In a culture obsessed with “what’s in it for me?” these natural obligations are framed as burdens, leaving society lonelier, less stable, and less invested in the future.
[RELATED: The Trans Shooter Stood No Chance of Getting the Help He Actually Needed]
Psychology promised empowerment, resilience, and self-acceptance—but delivered fragility, stagnation, and a generation so focused on protecting their egos that they’ve forgotten how to grow, contribute, or endure.
It’s time to reverse course. Self-respect should stem from achievement, not affirmation. Education must restore feedback as the lifeblood of learning. Society should reward improvement, not image. And individuals must learn the enduring lesson that worth is measured not by how you feel, but by what you do for and with others.
Until then, we will remain stuck in a culture where vanity is not just selfish but socially corrosive. We’ve turned inward, and it shows. The only way forward is to look outward again.
Image by Elnur on Adobe; Asset ID#: 289750364
