The University of California Does Not Like Criticism

“A Crisis of Competence: The Corrupting Effect of Political Activism in the University of California,” a recent report from the California Association of Scholars (CAS), detailed the radicalization and decline of the once-great UCal system. Charlotte Allen wrote about it here.

The report was prepared and sent to the regents, but University of California President Mark Yudof intervened with a dismissive reply to the CAS leadership. Here is his letter and the CAS response.

***

UPDATE

U California President Yudof Says Political Advocacy Is a Problem

By Ashley Thorne

From the National Association of Scholars site.

University of California president Mark Yudof appeared at the Chico Chamber of Commerce this Tuesday to hold a press conference and promote the University. He spoke to a group of businesspeople and the press concerning the “top ten myths” about UC. At the end of his talk was a question and answer time. Charles Geshekter, chairman of the California Association of Scholars and one of the authors of the new report A Crisis of Competence, asked President Yudof to describe what he sees as the difference between freedom of speech and academic freedom.

The Oroville Mercury-Register published an account of this exchange in “UC President: Faculty Should Educate, Not Proselytize.” Though Yudof was dismissive of the report’s claim that politicization in the classroom is linked to academic decline, he agreed that ideological bias is a problem. According to the Mercury-Register:

Yudof said there is some truth in the charge of faculty proselytizing. He said he doesn’t want to see classes “politicized.”

“Professors are there to educate — not to rouse the troops for a cause,” he said. They should not put on their websites that everyone should be pro-Israel or pro-Palestinian, for example.

The problem of inappropriate political advocacy by faculty aggravates him, Yudof said. But it’s difficult to do much about it, he added.

Dr. Geshekter commended the UC president on his articulate answer and asked him to support it:

Geshekter told Yudof he was pleased to hear that he recognized the problem. He asked the president if he couldn’t send a memo to all the UC campus chancellors condemning inappropriate political advocacy.

“I could do that,” Yudof said. “I don’t know that it would do much good.”

John Leo

John Leo

John Leo is the editor of Minding the Campus, dedicated to chronicling imbalances within higher education and restoring intellectual pluralism to our American universities. His popular column, "On Society," ran in U.S.News & World Report for 17 years.

One thought on “The University of California Does Not Like Criticism”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *