Frank Macchiarola, an Extraordinary Man


People reading Frank
Macchiarola’s obituary today will, no doubt, be struck at the variety of his
achievements. Frank, who wrote for this site,  was widely regarded as the
most successful New York Schools Chancellor, but he was also a success as a
Law School Dean, Chair of Charter Commissions, CEO of the NYC Partnership and
President of St Francis College.  I had worked with Frank in a few of
these roles.  But it was only after I became Scholar in Residence at St.
Francis that I saw the full dimensions of his extraordinary persona.

Slowly walking
through the halls of St Francis with Frank, a school of nearly 3,000 students
was itself an experience to remember.  I say slowly because every few
steps a student would stop Frank to speak with him. After a warm greeting, the
student would tell their college president what was new in their student
lives.  And like the best of the old time ward politicians – Frank who was
a member of the Thomas Jefferson Democratic Club in Brooklyn – knew each by
name and situation.

When Frank and I had
lunch it was smack in the middle of the student cafeteria where he ate
regularly.  And there as he and I talked about subjects such as the
over-financialization of the national economy, the fiscal misgovernance of New
York and the role of religion in enhancing democracy, we always paused when a
student came by. Frank would first tell the student what we were talking about –
suggesting that it was a topic he needed to pay attention to – then he would
listen to their concerns. 

Some would come by to
tell him that they had improved in their grades in an area where Frank had told
them they needed to pick up the pace. Others would lay out an ongoing problem.
He was warm but firm sometimes telling the student that they simply weren’t
working hard enough. This was in loco parentis in its very best
form.   Listening, I was struck not only by how much he knew about
each student but even more by his ability to connect with the student through
the problem at hand. In talking to him, the students, as they told me, realized
that he had really listened to them in their previous conversations. 

His father was a sanitation
worker who placed a high value on education. Frank attended St Francis as an
undergraduate before he went on to a law degree and a PhD. in Political Science
at Colombia.  What he wanted for today’s students, he told me, was the
same kind of personal attention he had received as young student in the early
1960s. Frank’s intelligence, warmth and concern suffuse the halls of St
Francis. The successes of the St Francis students he has nurtured will be an
important part of his legacy.


  • Fred Siegel

    Fred Siegel is a senior fellow of the Manhattan Institute's Center for State and Local Leadership, a City Journal contributing editor, and an expert on public policy solutions for urban governance. A former fellow at The Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, he is currently scholar-in-residence at Saint Francis College in Brooklyn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *